Pastoral Succession Planning: Why Pastors Struggle to Let Go w/ Karl Vaters – Episode 323

Pastoral Succession Planning: Why Pastors Struggle to Let Go w/ Karl Vaters – Episode 323

Karl Vaters has spent more than 40 years serving pastors and congregations in the small-church context. He’s the author of multiple books on church health and leadership, including the newly released De-Sizing the Church: How Church Growth Became a Science, Then an Obsession, and is widely known for helping pastors lead faithfully without chasing big-church metrics or growth formulas.

In this timely episode of the 95Podcast, Dale Sellers welcomes back Karl for another wide-ranging conversation—one shaped by decades of ministry experience and Karl’s recent global conversations with small-church pastors. Fresh from a seven-week world tour, Karl brings a global perspective to one of the most pressing challenges facing churches today: pastoral succession and retirement transitions.

Dale and Karl explore why so many leadership transitions fail, how pastors can avoid the “narrative void” that often follows retirement, and why discipleship—not strategy or size—is the key to long-term church health. With thousands of pastors nearing retirement and fewer new leaders entering ministry, this conversation offers clear, practical wisdom for pastors navigating transition, legacy, and the future of the local church—especially in small and midsize contexts.

More About Karl: 

Karl produces resources for Helping Small Churches Thrive at KarlVaters.com.

His heart is to help pastors of small churches (up to 90 percent of us) find the resources to lead well, and to capitalize on the unique advantages that come with pastoring a small church – something virtually every pastor will spend at least some of their ministry years doing. He also believes that big and small churches can and should work together more often – to the benefit and blessing of everyone.

Karl has served in small-church ministry for over 40 years, so he speaks and writes from decades of hands-on pastoral experience. He and his wife, Shelley have three children and two grandkids.

Karl also hosts a bi-weekly podcast, The Church Lobby: Conversations on Faith & Ministry. Episodes feature in-depth interviews about the topics that concern pastors, especially those who minister in a small church context.

Links to Resources Mentioned or Related

Key Takeaways

1) Start succession planning at the peak, not the decline.

2) Retiring pastors need a “next thing” to focus on in order to not feel useless.

3) Discipleship is the solution to most church problems.

4) Advanced preparation eliminates urgency. It will also free up a great deal of time for you once you’ve paid the dues to get started.

Subscribe (and Leave a Review!)

Be sure to subscribe to The 95 Podcast on whatever platform you prefer! You can also keep up with the latest podcasts, articles, and resources by using the form below:


Your rating also helps more pastors of small and mid-size churches find this resource, especially on Apple Podcasts. Would you take a moment to share your thoughts? Open the podcast on Apple Podcasts on your phone or computer and share your thoughts. We appreciate it!

Support the Podcast

The 95 Podcast is a ministry of 95Network. As a nonprofit, we rely on the support of those who believe in our mission to resource small and mid-size churches and support pastors. If this podcast or our ministry has impacted you, would you consider supporting us?

Share Your Thoughts on Social Media

Let’s keep the conversation going! You can keep up with our content by following us on TwitterFacebook, or LinkedIn.

Post & Podcast Categories

Posts & Podcasts by Month