Links to Resources Mentioned or Related

Key Takeaways

1) Plan Succession at Your Peak, Not Your Decline – The best time to plan leadership transition is when things are going well, not when momentum is lost. Pastors should initiate the conversation about stepping down while they can leave on a high note. A 2-3 year transition across teaching, board leadership, and staff leadership yields the best outcomes. The person waiting to succeed shouldn’t have to wait more than 3 years, or they’ll likely leave.

2) Metrics Reveal Decline Before It’s Visible – Attendance and finances are lagging indicators. Leading indicators like percentage serving, new people in the database, kids check-ins, and baptisms will show a decline first. Pay attention to these during “good times” so you can adjust strategies before gasping for air. Churches at sustained health must continuously monitor and reinvent to avoid the maintenance phase.

3) Focus on What Only You Can Do – Lead pastors must excel at three things: casting vision, teaching/spiritual leadership, and championing the mission. Everything else should be delegated to a team that complements weaknesses. Trying to be everything to everyone leads to burnout and ineffectiveness. Embrace interdependence—God designed the body of Christ to work together.

4) Simplify to Two Core Strategies – Stop doing 20 things poorly. Focus on (1) an effective weekend service that reaches new people, and (2) a clear discipleship pathway with simple steps. Most people stick when they serve (find their gifts), connect (find 3 friends), and give (generosity). Everything else should support these two strategies or be eliminated.

5) The Next Generation Is Spiritually Hungry – Gen Z and 28-40 year olds are showing up at churches ready to explore faith—many are first-time seekers, not returners. Churches focused on reaching this demographic with relevant methods (not just updating music) are experiencing significant growth. This is the moment to make strategic shifts and meet them where they are.

 

Subscribe (and Leave a Review!)

Be sure to subscribe to The 95 Podcast on whatever platform you prefer! You can also keep up with the latest podcasts, articles, and resources by using the form below:

Your rating also helps more pastors of small and mid-size churches find this resource, especially on Apple Podcasts. Would you take a moment to share your thoughts? Open the podcast on Apple Podcasts on your phone or computer and share your thoughts. We appreciate it!

Support the Podcast

The 95 Podcast is a ministry of 95Network. As a nonprofit, we rely on the support of those who believe in our mission to resource small and mid-size churches and support pastors. If this podcast or our ministry has impacted you, would you consider supporting us?

Share Your Thoughts on Social Media

Let’s keep the conversation going! We use #smallchurches on Twitter, and you can keep up with the latest by following us on Twitter (@95Network), Facebook, or Instagram.